When it comes to smoke-less fire pits, two brands immediately come to mind – Solo Stove and HY-C.
These two names have revolutionized the industry with the introduction of the Bonfire and the Flame Genie FG-16. Not only are these fire pits portable, but they’re super efficient, they give a clean burn, and they clean very easily.
But which of them should you choose? First, it pays to know their differences. For that reason, here’s a Solo Stove Bonfire vs Flame Genie FG-16 comparison report.
Comparison Chart: Solo Stove Bonfire vs Flame Genie FG-16
|Model||Check Price » Solo Stove Bonfire||Check Price » Flame Genie FG-16|
|Fuel||Firewood Logs||Wood Pellets|
|Material||304 Stainless steel||Galvanized Steel|
|Size||19.5 x 19.5 x 14 Inches||13.5 x 13.5 x 12.5 Inches|
|Weight||20 lbs||13.5 lbs|
|Unique Features||Double-Wall Construction, Holes on the Bottom and Top||2 Cylinders, Holes on the Bottom and Top|
Let’s talk about these fire pits’ main differences here.
The first obvious and most noticeable difference is the design (or shape) of these products.
The Bonfire comes with a singular construction, so when you take it out of the box, it’s ready to use. In comparison, the Flame Genie FG-16 is a 2-piece fire pit. When assembled, it resembles a pot with a larger base/bottom.
Solo Stove and HY-C have a unique way of describing these fire pits’ working mechanism, but if you read these descriptions closely, they speak of the same thing. Both have holes on the bottom and on top to draw in air to give you the following results: longer burn times, smoke-less burn, and secondary combustion.
Weight, Size, and Construction
The Bonfire weighs more than the Flame Genie. It weighs 20 pounds, and the Flame Genie FG-16 weighs 13.5 lbs.
When it comes to size, the Flame Genie is smaller. It has a diameter of 13.5 inches while the Bonfire has a diameter of 19.5 inches.
Based on the data we’ve gathered, these fire pits are made of different types of steel. Just like a lot of Solo Stove products, the Bonfire has a 304 stainless steel construction. The Flame Genie FG-16, on the other hand, is made of galvanized steel.
According to this site, galvanized steel is regular steel that has a zinc coating. Over time, when the coating erodes, the steel will eventuall rust. Stainless steel, on the other hand, is more resistant to rust.
Note, though, that the Flame Genie FG-16 has a stainless version, which you can find here.
Another difference between these two fire pits is their fuel requirement. The Bonfire requires firewood logs while the Flame Genie requires wood pellets.
If you live in a place where logs are abundant, then the Bonfire is definitely the better option. Wood pellets can be expensive.
Based on the fuel requirements, the Bonfire provides results that are close to what you can get from a traditional bonfire. Because Bonfire is fueled by wood logs, you can hear crackling sounds, and if you move closer to this fire pit, you’ll see some embers.
Wood pellets don’t give you these results.
Our Final Word: Solo Stove Bonfire vs Flame Genie FG-16
Which one should you get? Let’s end this Solo Stove Bonfire vs Flame Genie FG-16 comparison report with this recommendation.
The Solo Stove Bonfire is more expensive than the Flame Genie, but it’s better in giving you results that come close to a traditional bonfire. Also, the Bonfire is made of stainless steel, which is better than galvanized steel.